When evil is occurring, bystanders
need to step in. The German people should have stopped the Nazis but honestly I
don’t blame them. I believe most countries would have done the same exact
thing. When your family is starving and a political leader is claiming that he
can bring your country back to its feet, wouldn’t you follow him too? Wouldn’t you
blame the group for your poverty that your government blames? Then when your
country is thriving again and you can feed your family, wouldn’t you just
follow the man who did that? Most citizens didn’t know about concentration
camps but nothing of what I just said truly excuses them from ridiculing Jews
in the street. Honestly, I would have too though. I’d probably treat Jews bad
too so I didn’t get beat or imprisoned. In Macbeth, the bystanders really couldn’t
do anything because they didn’t know what was going on.
I
believe that those who carry out the orders are guilty but not of a capital crime.
What is the crime for disobeying orders in the US army? Well the punishment for
Nazi soldiers was even worse. Mostly likely in a US military court, the soldier
won’t be executed but in a Nazi Germany, there really wasn’t a trial…it was
pretty much stand by that wall and wait for a “lead injection” (if you know
what I mean) or have a date with a rope. Now those who did it out of fun and
pleasure can burn in Hell but those who were forced, I have sympathy for. For
the Nazi Pharmacist, I am not sure if he is truly guilty. He deserves jail time
but I don’t know if he is completely guilty. On the other hand he did decide to
kill certain people but could he have been forced? And it is true, if he did
refuse all of those Jews would have been killed anyway For the old soldier, I believe
he is one of the more innocent soldiers because he tried to make his camp
better. If it wasn’t for him many more POW’s may have been killed. In Macbeth’s case, that time, when your king
tells you to do something…you do it, no questions asked. You don’t just say no
to the ruler of your country who can do whatever they want. I have some sympathy
for the murderers because I don’t believe, that in that time, you can’t just
say no to your King.
I
believe the only way to stop evil is to have thousands of heroes. I believe the
American Revolution was standing up against evil (King George) and it took
thousands of people to stand up. I believe that, “When good people do nothing,
bad people can do bad things.” Those few that are willing to stand up to evil
by themselves are amazing people but are usually punished for it. That is why I
believe that most don’t stand up for their morals and fight evil. Evil will
always be present in the world because everyone is capable of being evil.
Hi Pat,
ReplyDeleteNice response to the writing prompt. I appreciated your honesty in admitting that you--put in the shoes of an average German citizen on the eve of WW2--would have probably ridiculed Jewish people as well. It is comforting to think of evil and evil actions as being external to and unincorporated with our selves. But put people in scenarios where doing the wrong thing seems right and is much easier than doing the right thing, and you might be surprised as to how people act. You did well to tie our reading of the play to the article's content. Good job.